While the video sharing market is hot, (or getting cooled off?) by the recent Google-YouTube acquisition, I had a chance to take a look into Microsoft’s foray in this domain – Soapbox.
As opposed to most of the new web based services from Microsoft coming under the Live.com branding, Soapbox is (at-least at the moment) branded under the MSN Videos brand umbrella. Maybe that is more-so to encash on the traffic that MSN Video is generating.
Coming to the service itself, there are something I immediately liked, and even thought are improvements from the current players (YouTube). Things like you can keep on browsing the videos while your current video is playing on the side. Soapbox has a neat AJAXy browse panel where you can see next videos, and your current video is playing on the right side, un-interrupted. Same goes for the comments, where you do have to scroll down, but not the whole page (like in Youtube, you miss the video when the scroll is wayyy down).
The current theme of User Interfaces that we are seeing from Microsoft camp (Live.com and its subsidiaries), are neat and airy. A user can feel breathing in those user interfaces. Not in Soapbox. To me, it was literally being in Soapbox, too tight and crushed. Maybe this is meant to happen if you want to show the active video surface on the same view as your browse controls. So I can live with it. But then the colors, since the site doesnt have any themes/skins, We are forced to live in the black/blue/gold color scheme, which adds to the tight/crushed feeling when you are in. This was the first time I was forced to use the Zoom functionality of my browser (IE7).
Are we ready to put it out on IE7? Because this might be some CSS issue, but going full screen on my browsers (IE7 exclusively) I do see a very bad looking panels on the bottom (if I scroll past down to the lower end). Looks kinda bad and un-professional. Hope this goes out in Release.
Coming down the actual video part, I dont think it is a Media Player in there, as speculated by lot of others, but is an embedded Flash Player. So, far I havent been able to view a single video in High Res, so kinda disappointed there. There was one High-Res video, but it kept on Buffering/Loading after every 5 seconds of play, on my DSL connection. So if it is bandwidth issues on Soapbox, it needs to go away before we come out of Beta.
Uploading your videos needs you to fill out a all required form. Again the controls are tight, low in height. Again the color combination of the site plays another negative for me. Fillable fields have black background, which is taking us away from a standard. Right now I am trying to upload a ~40MB video (.AVI) to see how the performance scales from what I see on my local machine, compared to what Soapbox shows me. I might need to post an update here once the upload is done. Its 28 minutes already.
Navigation: Navigating aids on the left side, are all you can want. The nice drop effect they have when you select something goes well. Videos can be tagged, so you can search for tags. Or you can search for categories. A tag cloud on the main page helps you find popular things right off the bat. Full marks as I said, for navigation and search.
There are some nice ways to report abuse OR Report a violation of your copyrighted material. I havent seen how this used to be in YouTube (I am sure there was a mechanism).
so, overall I would have loved to see it more relaxed, roomy interface. As I said, navigating and finding something is super easy. Browsing for more videos while actively seeing your current video is now possible!
Update: My upload finally finished and can be seen here:
Video: Euphoria – Mehfuz
Technorati tag: Soapbox, MSN Video
Sphere: Related Content